How China’s reprimand over Taiwan falls on deaf ears in Lithuania

How China’s reprimand over Taiwan falls on deaf ears in Lithuania

Post by

China recalled its ambassador to Lithuania on Tuesday over the Baltic nation’s transfer to permit Taiwan to open a diplomatic outpost in Vilnius.

“The choice overtly violates the spirit of the communique on the institution of diplomatic relations between China and Lithuania and severely undermines China’s sovereignty and territorial integrity,” China’s international ministry mentioned in a press release.

“The Chinese language authorities expresses its categorical opposition to this transfer,” it added, saying that Beijing has known as again its ambassador, Shen Zhifei, and requested the Lithuanian authorities to recall its ambassador to China, Diana Mickeviciene.

Ms Mickeviciene had already been in Lithuania for a while when China issued its offended response. The fallout between the 2 nations was nicely anticipated as Lithuania grew more and more cautious of China’s affect in Europe and extra supportive of Taiwan.

China considers Taiwan to be a part of its territory and has threatened to unify the 2 sides by drive, if vital, which president Xi Jinping has described as a “historic mission”.

Xi pledged to unify Taiwan with mainland China through the celebrations of the a hundredth anniversary of the Communist Occasion


Beijing has lengthy required that international locations minimize their ties with Taiwan in an effort to set up relations with China. That is known as the “One China” coverage, which is recognised by the US, the UK and EU.

Its aggressive response to Lithuania is known to be a warning shot to different European international locations to discourage them from following the identical instance.

Lithuania’s determination was “politically brave and important”, Didi Kirsten Tatlow, a senior fellow on the German Council on Overseas Relations in Berlin, advised The Unbiased.

In March 1990, when Lithuania was within the midst of its violent break from the Soviet Union, Iceland gave the small Baltic nation hope by changing into the primary nation on this planet to recognise its independence. It was then known as the “Iceland second”, an emotional historic flip that boosted the morale of a nation in despair. Now many in Lithuania are fervent supporters of affording Taiwan its “Iceland second”.

“Lithuania, which has a long-term damaging historic expertise with Russia and shares borders with Belarus, identifies with Taiwan and sees the cross-strait concern by the prism of its personal historic expertise with non-democratic regimes,” Ivana Karaskova, chief of China Observers in Central and Japanese Europe (CHOICE), mentioned.

The overall elections in Lithuania elevated a centre-right alliance to energy. One of many central marketing campaign slogans was a “values-based international coverage”. The driving drive behind this method is the younger and impressive international minister Gabrielius Landsbergis, the grandson of Vytautas Landsbergis, a distinguished opponent of the Soviet communist rule and Lithuania’s first parliament speaker after independence.

Since then, Lithuania tended to undertake a extra hawkish coverage in the direction of authoritarian international locations, like China, Russia and Belarus.

“Lithuania has a painful historical past of Soviet Communism, so it has a real home curiosity in standing up for democracy. It understands, maybe higher than others within the older Western European democracies, why it’s value defending and enlarging even when it’s powerful and requires sacrifices,” Dr Tatlow mentioned.

Lithuania has a painful historical past of Soviet Communism, so it has a real home curiosity in standing up for democracy.

Ivana Karaskova, chief of China Observers in Central and Japanese Europe (CHOICE)

However, for Beijing, the identify of the proposed de facto embassy is a vastly contentious concern. The potential diplomatic workplace could be known as “Taiwan consultant workplace”, in a transparent break free from the classical euphemism “Taipei” commerce workplace, utilized in the remainder of Europe and past.

This may make it the primary such workplace in Europe to signify Taiwan by its identify, which China considers a violation of the “One China” coverage.

Earlier than that, Lithuania had hoped to learn from its membership of China’s “17+1” block with central and jap Europe to deal with a hovering commerce deficit and profit from China’s blueprint Belt and Highway Initiative tasks. However this has not been realised as China lagged behind on its funding guarantees and centered as a substitute on organising excessive profile diplomatic conferences.

The full Chinese language funding in Lithuania was estimated to be round simply £70m final yr, in accordance with the Central and Japanese Europe Centre for Asian Research. This quantities to round 0.4 per cent of Lithuania’s whole international direct funding. The United Nations COMTRADE database on worldwide commerce exhibits China’s exports to Lithuania reached £1bn in 2020, whereas China imported Lithuanian items value merely £258m the identical yr.

Lithuania has, subsequently, determined to withdraw from the “17+1” in Might, calling on all EU members to drag out. “From our perspective, it’s excessive time for the EU to maneuver from a dividing 16+1 format to a extra uniting and subsequently rather more environment friendly 27+1,” Mr Landsbergis advised Politico again then. “The EU is strongest when all 27 member states act collectively together with EU establishments.”

Comparable insurance policies would often entice Beijing’s wrath, as was evident in China turning the financial screws on Australia final yr after it had known as for an investigation into the Covid-19 origin.

Lithuania’s international minister Gabrielius Landsbergis is main a values-based international coverage


However the low charge of Chinese language funding and financial engagement with Lithuania was seen as a blessing. It meant Vilnius was capable of pursue a comparatively aggressive coverage in the direction of China as a response to its assertiveness within the Indo-Pacific area and Xinjiang with out fearing retaliation.

Concurrently, Lithuania’s parliament joined different governments in describing China’s therapy of its Uyghur minority as “genocide”. It additionally voted to name for a UN investigation of internment camps, and requested the European Fee to evaluate relations with Beijing.

“The current shift in tone is an effective expression of the general altering sentiment in Europe, and in a means, Lithuania is making use of its very restricted dependence on China,” Janka Oertel, Director of the Asia programme on the European Council on Overseas Relations, advised The Unbiased.

The EU voiced cautious opposition to China’s transfer. “That is the primary time China has recalled an Ambassador in an EU Member State for opening … an workplace in Taiwan,” an EU spokesperson mentioned on Tuesday. “We remorse the Chinese language motion and are following developments intently.”

The spokesperson mentioned: “Essentially, it is a bilateral matter between China and Lithuania. Having mentioned that, the event of China’s bilateral relations with the person EU member states inevitably has an influence on total EU-China relations.”

The EU “delicate” method has lengthy antagonised Lithuania and lots of smaller international locations within the EU who grew to become satisfied that the veto of France and Germany over the bloc’s insurance policies in the direction of Beijing has to finish.

In December final yr, the 2 main powers signed the historic Complete Settlement on Funding that might grant China better entry to EU markets. The European Parliament later shelved the settlement after Beijing imposed financial sanctions on its outspoken members on the human rights state of affairs in China.

However signing the deal was seen by many throughout the EU as a rushed transfer spearheaded by Paris and Berlin.

“The Franco-German domination within the EU, whereas meant as a means to make sure the Union and its core stay sturdy after Brexit, could backfire by more and more alienating smaller states that don’t really feel represented,” Dr Tatlow mentioned.

The Franco-German domination within the EU could backfire by more and more alienating smaller states that don’t really feel represented

Kirsten Tatlow, a Senior Fellow on the German Council on Overseas Relations

“A primary instance of this was the CAI funding cope with China that was pushed by Germany, with France given particular entry. It was not fashionable in all places in Europe,” she famous.

“That is an fascinating message to Paris and Berlin that there are various completely different voices in Europe on these questions and that EU member states will make their impartial choices that should be factored in in future technique discussions,” Dr Oertel famous.

In the meantime, Lithuania’s new method began to draw Washington’s consideration as a brand new entrance towards authoritarianism with continental ambitions. And this coverage began to repay.

The small Baltic nation has already scored features. In June, it was introduced that the 2023 Nato summit could be held in Lithuania, and former president Dalia Grybauskaite has develop into a critical contender for the function of Nato normal secretary.

“Not all of that is, after all, related to the Lithuanian change of method to China – Russia and Belarus have additionally been factored in,” Dr Karaskova mentioned.

China is anticipated to stress Lithuania to take a step again in its relations with Taiwan. However it’s unclear whether or not the Lithuanian authorities could be able to take Beijing’s warnings significantly.

“This may all nonetheless be de-escalated, and certain will, however the query is what if not? In a means, it is usually an fascinating take a look at case of how a lot China’s assertive rhetoric is extra bark than chew,“ Dr Oertel mentioned.

Leave a comment