Kais Saied’s power grab in Tunisia

Kais Saied’s energy seize in Tunisia

Post by


On July 25, Tunisian President Kais Saied froze the parliament, dismissed the prime minister, and introduced he’ll quickly rule by decree. Flanked by navy and safety officers, Saied additionally rescinded parliamentary immunity, threatening to topic corrupt parliamentarians to the regulation “regardless of their wealth and positions.” On July 26, he additionally issued a nationwide curfew for 30 days.

Saied’s energy seize represents a serious check for Tunisia’s younger democracy, as severe because the protests in 2013 that just about derailed its preliminary transition. How Tunisian and worldwide audiences react to Saied’s announcement will probably form whether or not the nation stays the world’s solely Arab democracy, or falls to what political scientists name a “self-coup” or incumbent takeover.

Roots of the disaster

Regardless of transitioning to democracy and approving a progressive structure by means of consensus, Tunisia because the 2011 revolution has been hit onerous by a sluggish financial system, perceptions of corruption, and rising disillusionment with political events. These tendencies fueled the rise of Saied, an impartial regulation professor who gained a landslide victory within the 2019 presidential elections. Regardless of his reputation, Tunisia’s 2014 structure laid out a semi-presidential system during which Saied would share energy with a first-rate minister who traces his authority to the parliament. That divided system has all however stalled political exercise in Tunisia, with President Saied, Prime Minister Hichem Mechichi, and parliamentary speaker Rached Ghannouchi over the previous yr repeatedly at loggerheads concerning their respective powers. These divisions have produced an incoherent strategy in the direction of the COVID-19 pandemic, which has solely exacerbated Tunisia’s financial and political malaise.

On this local weather, Saied’s energy seize represents for some a clear break from a struggling transition, providing hope {that a} stronger presidency unencumbered by what Saied lately referred to as the “locks” within the 2014 structure would possibly enable him to place the financial system again on observe and root out corruption within the political class. However moderately than negotiating a constitutional revision, Saied has seized energy outright, freezing the parliament and dismissing the prime minister by decree. Ghannouchi, the parliamentary speaker, accordingly slammed Saied’s strikes as “a coup towards the revolution and structure.” The parliament’s 4 largest events — together with the Islamist events Ennahda and the Karama Coalition and the secular events Qalb Tounes and the Democratic Present — amongst others have additionally condemned Saied’s actions as unconstitutional.

A “constitutional” coup?

President Saied, previously a constitutional regulation professor, claims to have acted in accordance with Article 80 of Tunisia’s structure, which allows the president to assert distinctive powers for 30 days “within the occasion of imminent hazard” to the state or its functioning. Nonetheless, even a layperson’s studying of Article 80 can see that it additionally mandates that the prime minister and parliamentary speaker be consulted, and that the parliament stay in “a state of steady session all through such a interval,” not frozen.

Sadly, the one physique that might adjudicate whether or not Article 80 was appropriately utilized — and, for that matter, the one physique that in response to Article 80 can finish Saied’s distinctive powers — is the constitutional court docket, which nonetheless doesn’t exist. Though its creation was mandated by the 2014 structure, Tunisia’s fractured political panorama has prevented events from coming to an settlement on the court docket’s membership.

From unhealthy to worse

With no judicial answer, the disaster has as an alternative escalated in a extra contentious path up to now 24 hours. Late Sunday evening, Ghannouchi, deputy speaker Samira Chaouachi, and different parliamentary leaders tried to defy Saied’s decree and maintain a session of parliament, according to the structure.

Nonetheless, a military unit stationed exterior of the parliament blocked their entry. On the one hand, it may be argued that the Tunisian navy, a traditionally skilled and apolitical power, was merely following the president’s orders (regardless of their shaky constitutional foundations). Nonetheless, intentional or not, its actions have additionally had main political penalties, creating perceptions that the military is likely to be loyal to Saied and solidifying impressions that this was certainly a “self-coup.” Saied’s dismissal of the minister of protection fed additional rumors that he was trying to safe the navy’s loyalty for what could come within the days and weeks forward.

The police, for his or her half, have additionally seemingly proven their loyalty to Saied up to now 24 hours, most notably by storming the Al-Jazeera workplace in a transparent violation of press freedom. Tunisian media additionally reported that Saied tasked the pinnacle of his presidential guard, Khaled Yahyaoui, with the obligations of inside minister. On condition that the police have undergone little safety sector reform because the revolution, persevering with to commit widespread abuses, they might additionally play a important function in consolidating Saied’s coup try.

Equally worrisome was the response of the Tunisian Normal Labor Union (UGTT), which gained a Nobel Peace Prize for its function in brokering negotiations that solved Tunisia’s 2013 disaster. Nonetheless, moderately than a impartial assertion urging dialogue, the UGTT as an alternative appeared supportive of Saied’s actions, saying they have been according to the structure, however expressing issues that he keep on with 30 days and never increase his powers additional.

The highway forward

Though most political events opposed Saied’s actions, the dearth of opposition (and even seeming help) from the navy, police, and UGTT means that Saied won’t again down anytime quickly. Transferring ahead, the disaster is prone to escalate, with either side egging on their supporters to take to the streets.

The end result of the disaster can be formed partly by who can mobilize extra supporters to “vote with their toes.” At this stage, the steadiness of energy seems to favor Saied. Though he now not enjoys the 87% approval score he did in 2019 (polls at this time put him nearer to 40%), he stays the most well-liked determine in Tunisia. Past his base, Tunisians searching for a stronger presidency, in addition to these hostile in the direction of political events and in the direction of Ennahda particularly, may additionally approve of his decrees. That stated, most political events have come out towards the coup, and can probably mobilize in vital numbers as effectively.

However the dueling protests that already emerged at this time additionally make the state of affairs much more risky, elevating the specter of clashes between the 2 sides. Stopping that potential for violence requires Saied and the political events to deescalate and negotiate a method out of the disaster. Important to observe on this regard would be the place of the UGTT and different civil society actors: how lengthy till they step in as soon as once more to assist mediate a method out of this disaster?

One other essential issue to observe is the response of the worldwide neighborhood. Except for Turkey, which got here out strongly towards Saied’s “suspension of the democratic course of,” most international locations and our bodies that weighed in (Germany, the European Union, the U.N., and the U.S.) typically adopted a “wait-and-see” strategy, expressing concern and urging restraint and dialogue. But if the world’s democracies don’t come out strongly towards the coup try, it leaves a chance for counterrevolutionary powers like Saudi Arabia and the United Arab Emirates to affect the disaster in help of Saied, very similar to they did for Egypt’s Abdel-Fattah el-Sissi. With Tunisia’s financial system within the doldrums, international help — and support — could effectively form the result of this disaster, for good or for in poor health.


Leave a comment