When the FBI infiltrates a Bible study, why does CNN say it was a fake 'Bible study'? — GetReligion

When the FBI infiltrates a Bible examine, why does CNN say it was a faux ‘Bible examine’? — GetReligion

Post by


From time to time, one comes throughout a information story that’s past odd.

Ever because the Jan. 6 assault on the U.S. Capitol, legislation enforcement has been making an attempt to get to the underside as to who and what have been the planners for all this. Everyone knows that. However this time round, the FBI infiltrated one thing new — a Bible examine in Alexandria.

Or, as many media are saying, a “Bible examine.”

Have a look at this a part of a CNN piece. The hot button is to attempt to discover some info on a particular non secular establishment or motion linked to this exercise:

The FBI has infiltrated a “Bible examine” group in Virginia that after the January 6 riot had members discussing surveilling the US Capitol and their want for secession from the US, and investigators intently adopted one member’s plans to construct and take a look at Molotov cocktails, in line with lately unsealed court docket information.

The newly disclosed legal case towards Virginia man Fi Duong — who additionally goes by “Monkey King” and “Jim,” in line with the court docket document — arose after Duong interacted with undercover legislation enforcement officers a number of occasions on January 6 and into current months, when the FBI finally gained entry to his group in Virginia then accompanied him to an previous jail as Duong allegedly pursued bomb-building.

Seems to be like an FBI agent befriended Duong and commenced hanging out with him and his mates.

Duong advised the FBI agent that his group tried to be “cloak and dagger” and needed to “construct resistances,” in line with court docket information. The agent then attended what the group members known as a “Bible examine” assembly at an Alexandria, Virginia, home in February, the place the group members mentioned the Bible and secession, weaponry and fight coaching, and utilizing strategies to make their communications non-public, in line with court docket information.

One particular person within the group commented on the assembly about creating “a semi-autonomous area” for Virginia. “I just like the Structure; I do not just like the Democratic sh*t this area retains voting for,” the particular person mentioned, in line with the FBI.

I’m curious why the scare quotes are put round this Bible examine group when it’s apparent there actually was dialogue in regards to the Bible at this gathering. I listened to CNN’s video alongside the article and the reporter known as the gathering “a so-called Bible examine assembly.” Oh, and is there a church linked to this? A parachurch group or another group?

Curious, however how did she comprehend it was “so-called?” We all know there was some scriptural content material to this assembly. For CNN to imagine this was a faux assembly reveals fairly the disdain for faith, though linked to politics it might have been.

The article additionally talked about further conferences. Had been these too Bible research or one thing else?

Extra particulars, please. As soon as once more, we see proof of a development that has been mentioned right here at GetReligion time and again in recent times: journalists appear to battle when masking completely unbiased non secular congregations and teams. It’s one factor when an unbiased, remoted group holds a gathering of this type. It could be a much bigger story if it was a circle of males linked to a serious evangelical denomination or a parachurch group, maybe one thing like Promise Keepers.

In the meantime, the considered the FBI creeping into your neighbor’s examine of the Gospel of St. Mark is simply odd to most Christians, and there’s some thought that the FBI tried to entrap these Bible examine members into planning violence.

Should say, within the West, it’s been awhile that the Bible was thought of subversive sufficient to be grounds for arrest. This goes on in China on a regular basis, however … northern Virginia?

In case you’re questioning if there may be precedent, Muslims have been enduring related infiltration for 20 years.

The FBI has infiltrated Islamic teams loads of occasions and a current article in The Hill tells how the Supreme Court docket lately agreed to listen to a case concerning some California mosques that have been infiltrated by an FBI informant.

It was generally assumed {that a} well-known Virginia mosque (one I as soon as lived just some miles away from) known as Dar al-Hijrah Islamic Middle in Falls Church, was infiltrated by the FBI on a regular basis. (After all it didn’t assist that two of the Sept. 11 hijackers — Hani Hanjour and Nawaf Alhazmi – worshipped there months earlier than the assault).

Plus, the New York Police Division infiltrated, mapped or surveyed 250 mosques and 31 Muslim scholar organizations, in line with this examine.

Nonetheless, reporters didn’t use pejorative phrases corresponding to “so-called Muslim worshippers” to explain what went on there.

CNN may disagree with what went on at this “so-called Bible examine,” however paperwork did say that “the Bible and secession” have been mentioned.

This isn’t to say the FBI can’t examine teams utilizing faith as a canopy for legal conduct. Again within the Forties, J. Edgar Hoover, then head of the FBI, thought of mainline Protestant clergy as Communist sympathizers and due to this fact subversive. However actuality is extra advanced. There could also be legal conduct, however there’s true non secular follow taking place too.

Based on a 2017 e-book “The FBI and Faith: Religion and Safety Earlier than and After 9/11,” the FBI has infiltrated a number of non secular teams — however 9/11 was a recreation changer. Its failure to forestall 9/11 incentivized the Bureau to have sufficient brokers on the market reporting on Muslims, in order that no related assault will occur once more. The Atlantic did an fascinating assessment of the e-book right here.

Northern Virginia is combed with church buildings and Bible examine teams, a few of which I used to attend throughout the 12 years I lived there. I by no means thought I’d see the day when the FBI would take into account such mundane gatherings worthy of surveillance. However after they do, reporters ought to attempt to get some context to all of it. Was the gathering linked to any specific church? What biblical content material was studied there?

Likelihood is they’ll discover a bizarre mixture of God and weapons. And it’s a significantly better story if the reporter makes it clear there was some God mentions on the occasion, reasonably than assuming that the religion was faux.

FIRST IMAGE: Bible examine by Godsgirl_madi from Pixabay.

Leave a comment